Costs …. mutants.

I think mutants should be 7 points.

Ork Boyz are a bit undercosted at 6, they are a bargain now (especially shoota boyz IMO).  I do want mutants to be able to stand up to orks for a similar amount of points, and be a bit scary as a cc unit while still be cheap enough to be able to field lots of them.

The point was made that mutants are a big step up from traitors set for close combat, which is valid.  a 2 point increase over “warrior weapons” guardsmen is more fair than 1 for an extra attack and toughness.  Still, guardsmen are supposed to be better at shooting so it’s not exactly cut out to be a CC troop like Ork boyz are.

Here’s what they are gaining and losing compared to a Slugga boy:

Gaining:

  • Flak (5+)  Not a great save but handy in close combat.  This makes them more survivable than boyz when stuck in
  • I3 always instead of just charging
  • No wounds from losing combat and being Fearless
  • Flamer option
  • Frag grenades
  • Possible infiltration (I think it should be +4 points instead of +3, considering kommandos)

Losing:

  • They won’t be hitting as hard on the charge.  Losing a point of S there is big.
  • Shooting: This isn’t a big loss, as most slugga boy mobs run now. I think I will give the mutants a laspistol to fit in with the fluff about firearms, so they have something at least for flavor.
  • Ork leadership bonuses, being fearless helps against shooting
  • Waaaagh fleet move once a game
  • Rokkits and Big Shootas (should mutants keep big shootas?  It is flavorful, since heavy stubbers aren’t in.)
  • Powerklaws (although big mutants can do some good damage)
  • Transport options
  • Mutants have Rage (conditioned on having no character) but it won’t be a problem too often.

Here’s some mathammer results:

Same points cost:
30 slugga boyz charge 25 mutants = 20 dead mutants, 10.4 dead orks,     140 points of mutants to 62.4  points of orks  /  Orks win by 9.6 wounds
25 mutants charge 30 orks = 13.8 dead orks, 8 dead mutants   1.7 to 1      82.8 points of orks to 56 points of mutants / Mutants win by 5.8 wounds

Same amount of models:
30 slugga boyz charge 30 mutants = 20 dead mutants, 12.5 dead orks      140 points of mutants to 75 points of orks  /  Orks win by 7.5 wounds
30 mutants charge 30 orks = 16.6 dead orks, 6.7 dead mutants       99.6 points of orks  to 45.5 points of mutants / Mutants win by 9.9 wounds

Also, I want to run some mathammer on Chaos Spawn vs. Fiends and Bloodcrushers to see if 25 points is too low.

Advertisements

About chaosgerbil

I'm an artist and hobbyist.
This entry was posted in Codex: Lost And The Damned. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s